Villa Hideaway
A private pool and sun deck, about a one-minute walk from Orient Bay Beach, with restaurants and the bakery close by.
See the villaWhich side is better?
French beaches and long lunches, or lively beach bars and waterfront resorts? Here's what really changes when you cross from one side of the island to the other.
Updated October 2026
St Martin and St Maarten share one island, but your choice of where to stay can make a real difference to your vacation. The good news? You can enjoy both sides, no matter where you book.
On the French side, think beach restaurants, small hotels, villas and evenings spent discovering somewhere new to eat. On the Dutch side, you’ll find busier waterfront towns, casinos, beach bars and a bigger selection of resorts.
Neither is automatically the better choice. Here’s what each side is like, where to stay and what’s worth knowing before you book.
Start here
First things first: St Martin and St Maarten are two names you'll hear for the same island. Saint-Martin is the French territory in the north; Sint Maarten is the Dutch territory in the south.
The island covers about 87 km², and its two territories have shared it since the 17th century. There’s no routine border checkpoint when you drive from one side to the other. You may only notice the change when the road signs, shop names or currency on a menu look different.
The French side is part of France; the Dutch side is a country within the Kingdom of the Netherlands. Both have their own character, services and regulations, but tourists can explore the island as a whole.
So don't think of this as choosing one island and missing the other. You're simply deciding where you'd prefer to wake up each morning.
One island, two very different atmospheres — and no need to limit your vacation to just one.
Saint-Martin
Come for the beaches, restaurants and smaller places to stay. Plan on exploring a little.
The French side is a lovely choice if your plans involve exploring beaches, finding a good place for lunch and spending evenings at a restaurant rather than a casino.
Grand Case is the place to go for dinner, with everything from local lolos to more elaborate French-Caribbean cooking. In Orient Bay, you can spend the day on the sand and walk to several restaurants without getting back in the car.
Marigot has the market, waterfront cafés and a more everyday island feel. A little farther out, you'll find quieter spots like Friar's Bay, Anse Marcel and the beaches around Terres Basses.
There are plenty of vacation rentals, villas and smaller hotels, but fewer large resort-style properties. In most areas, a rental car is very useful, especially if you want to try a different beach each day.
One thing to keep in mind: the French side isn't quiet everywhere. Orient Bay can be lively, particularly around its beach restaurants. If seclusion is your priority, choose your neighborhood carefully.
If you like choosing a new beach or restaurant whenever the mood strikes, the French side gives you plenty to work with.
Yellow Beach restaurant on Pinel Island
Orient Bay · Villa · 3 bedrooms · Sleeps 6
A private pool and sun deck, about a one-minute walk from Orient Bay Beach, with restaurants and the bakery close by.
See the villa
Orient Bay · Studio · Sleeps 2
A poolside studio at Alamanda, for couples who want Orient Bay Beach a few steps away.
Check dates
Orient Bay · Condo · 2 bedrooms · Sleeps 4
A two-bedroom duplex at Alamanda with a sea-view terrace, pool access and the beach steps away.
Check datesSint Maarten
More resorts, more nightlife and plenty of dining options, especially around Simpson Bay and Maho.
The Dutch side has more of the classic vacation-resort atmosphere, with waterfront hotels, casinos, nightlife and busy shopping streets. That doesn't mean every neighborhood feels the same.
Philipsburg is known for its boardwalk, shops and cruise-ship visitors. It's fun for a day out, though it can get crowded when several ships are in port. Simpson Bay is a different scene: marinas, restaurants, beach bars and plenty of places to spend an evening.
Around Maho, you'll find resorts, a casino and the famous beach where aircraft pass overhead on their way to the airport. Cupecoy is another option, with condos and coastal views, while areas farther from the main strip can feel considerably quieter.
You'll generally have more choice if you want a large hotel or an all-inclusive resort. You can also stay in an apartment or beachfront condo and explore independently, just as you would on the French side.
If restaurants, nightlife and convenient access to resort amenities are high on your list, start your accommodation search here.
The Dutch side is a great fit if you want restaurants and entertainment close to your hotel — though quieter corners exist here too.
Holland House Hotel in Philipsburg
Photo: Booking.com
Simpson Bay · Apartment · 1 bedroom · Lagoon view
Apartments with a lagoon-view balcony and a rooftop pool, on the Simpson Bay waterfront.
Check datesPhoto: Vrbo
Simpson Bay · Penthouse · 2 bedrooms · Sleeps 4
A top-floor condo with direct beach access, sea views and sunsets, plus a backup generator and Starlink.
Check dates
Cupecoy · Condo · 3 bedrooms
Ocean views, a resort pool and a secluded beach and cave reached by a spiral staircase, in a gated residence.
See the condoSide by side
| What matters to you | French side — Saint-Martin | Dutch side — Sint Maarten |
|---|---|---|
| Beaches | Beautiful beaches with everything from lively Orient Bay to quiet coves. | Mullet Bay, Great Bay and Simpson Bay are popular choices; Maho is best known for plane spotting. |
| Food & restaurants | Grand Case is a highlight for French-Caribbean dining and beachside meals. | Excellent variety around Simpson Bay, with international and Caribbean options. |
| Nightlife & casinos | Mostly relaxed evenings, with restaurants and some beach bars. | More casinos, bars and late-night venues, particularly near Simpson Bay and Maho. |
| Shopping | Markets, independent boutiques and shops around Marigot. | Duty-free shopping is a major draw in Philipsburg. |
| Hotels & accommodation | Villas, apartments, boutique hotels and smaller resorts. | A wider selection of large resorts, all-inclusives, hotels and condos. |
| Pace & atmosphere | Village restaurants, beach days and exploring by car. | Busy resort areas as well as quieter residential neighborhoods. |
| Families | Villas and family rentals, plus beaches to explore. | Family-friendly resorts and more on-site activities. |
| First-time visitors | Good for travelers who like independent trips and trying different beaches. | A convenient option if you prefer a full-service hotel or resort. |
| Where to stay | See places to stay on the French side | See places to stay on the Dutch side |
My honest answer
The best base is the one that suits your vacation, not the one that wins a comparison chart.
I'd choose based on where you want to spend your evenings and how much you plan to explore during the day.
For beach-hopping, boutique hotels, villas and long dinners in Grand Case, look first at the French side. Orient Bay is especially convenient if you'd rather walk to the beach and restaurants than drive everywhere.
For all-inclusive resorts, casinos, shopping and a livelier nightlife scene, look at the Dutch side — particularly Maho and Simpson Bay. You can still get to French-side beaches and restaurants easily by car.
French side for beaches, villas and leisurely dinners; Dutch side for resorts, nightlife and convenience. You can enjoy both either way.
Both sides
Two sides, two different atmospheres. Why not experience both?
If you're staying for a week or longer, splitting your vacation between the French and Dutch sides can be a great idea. And it's actually something many visitors choose to do.
You could spend four nights on the Dutch side, enjoying the beach bars, nightlife, shopping and lively atmosphere around Simpson Bay, then move to the French side for five nights of beautiful beaches, long lunches and evenings in Grand Case. Or do it the other way around!
It's also a chance to enjoy two completely different places to stay — perhaps a beachfront resort on one side and a charming boutique hotel on the other.
Of course, you don't have to change hotels to explore the island. Saint Martin is small enough to discover both sides from one base, although traffic can make some journeys longer than expected.
My advice? If you're visiting for just a few days, choose one base and explore. But if you have 8, 9 or 10 nights to enjoy, splitting your stay is definitely worth considering. It's a lovely way to experience two sides of Caribbean life in one vacation.
On the boardwalk in Philipsburg
A quick practical note before you decide
Whichever side you stay on, renting a car makes a significant difference. The island is small but spread out — the best beaches, restaurants, and viewpoints don’t cluster around any single spot. With a car, you can move freely between sides and explore on your own schedule.
Good to know
Currency. The euro is used on the French side, and the Caribbean guilder (XCG) is the official currency on the Dutch side. US dollars are widely accepted, particularly in tourist areas. Check the exchange rate a business uses before paying in another currency. Currency guide
Language. French is the official language on the French side, while Dutch and English are official on the Dutch side. English is widely spoken across the island, especially in hotels and restaurants.
Driving. You drive on the right on both sides. There are no routine passport checks at the internal border, but traffic can be slow around Simpson Bay and the main roads during busy periods. Driving tips
Shopping and taxes. Philipsburg is particularly popular for duty-free shopping. Tax rules differ between the French and Dutch sides, so check the price and any applicable tax before making a large purchase.
Food. Grand Case is famous for its restaurants, while Simpson Bay has a broad mix of international and Caribbean cuisines. There are affordable and upscale choices on both sides; it depends where you go.
Beaches. For Orient Bay, Friar's Bay and Baie Rouge, head to the French side. For Mullet Bay, Simpson Bay and Maho, head to the Dutch side. Explore the beaches
Safety. Use the same common-sense precautions on both sides: secure valuables, avoid leaving belongings in parked cars and be careful in isolated areas after dark. Safety tips
Live availability
Frequently asked questions
Saint-Martin is the French territory in the north; Sint Maarten is the Dutch territory in the south. Both share the same island, and people often use ‘St Martin’ to refer to the whole destination.
You can normally cross the internal border by car without stopping for passport control. Keep your travel documents available, however, as the French and Dutch territories have different entry rules.
Both sides have excellent beaches. On the French side, try Orient Bay, Friar's Bay or Baie Rouge. On the Dutch side, Mullet Bay is a favorite for swimming, and Maho is famous for watching aircraft. Your preference depends on whether you want beach restaurants, quieter coves or a lively setting.
Grand Case on the French side is especially well known for its restaurants and local lolos. Simpson Bay on the Dutch side also has an excellent variety of dining options. Food lovers will be happy exploring both.
The Dutch side has more casinos, clubs and late-night bars, especially around Simpson Bay and Maho. The French side is more focused on dinner, beach restaurants and quieter evenings.
It depends on your hotel, travel dates and dining choices. You'll find both inexpensive and high-end options on either side. Compare accommodations rather than assuming one entire side is cheaper.
Choose the French side if you're excited about villas, beaches and dining out around Grand Case or Orient Bay. Choose the Dutch side if you want a resort, casino or nightlife nearby. In both cases, you can easily explore the rest of the island.
Absolutely. Philipsburg is busy on cruise-ship days, but the Dutch side also includes Simpson Bay, Mullet Bay, Cupecoy and quieter residential areas. It's worth discovering beyond the cruise port.
Some links on this page are affiliate links. When you book through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.